top of page

Cedar vs Redwood Fence: Which Material is Better?

Updated: Mar 20

cedar vs redwood fence boards

A fence can be more than just a boundary marker. It's a statement piece, a reflection of your style, and a protector of your cherished space.

Yet, finding the right type of fence can be perplexing with a multitude of fencing materials to choose from. This guide will help you choose between two of the most common choices: cedar vs redwood fence.

Which wood reigns supreme when you're hunting for durability, aesthetics, and value? Many homeowners find themselves torn between these two popular fencing materials, with each offering its unique blend of charm and functionality.

But, there is a clear winner in this debate - and that’s cedar fencing. We’ll explain why as we dive deep into the nuances between redwood vs cedar fence boards below. First, a quick word on the role of fencing materials…

Quality Cedar Products can meet all your cedar board needs. This blog is informational only and not a replacement for expert advice. Please consult a professional before starting any building project as your needs and specifications may vary and it may not reflect the most current building codes, regulations, or industry standards.

The Role of Fencing Materials

The fencing material you choose sets the tone for your property. It’s not just about marking boundaries. It's about aesthetics, longevity, functionality, and, to a large extent, the value it adds to your property.

The material decides how frequently you'd be out there maintaining it, how your neighbors perceive your property, and the first impression it casts on visitors.

Building a Beautiful Fence That You’re Proud of

The allure of a fence comes from its design, the hue of its wood, its height, and the craftsmanship that goes into installing it.

Whether you’re aiming for an ornate look or something minimalist and modern, the quality and type of wood play a significant role in the end product.

Cedar and redwood, for example, boast a natural beauty that many other materials simply can't replicate. They carry with them a certain rustic charm and sophistication that enhance a property’s curb appeal. We have a list of stunning cedar fence ideas if you’re looking for inspiration - but appearance is just one piece of the puzzle.

Considerations Beyond the Aesthetic Appeal

While a beautiful fence is undoubtedly a pride for homeowners, it's crucial to look beyond the surface. A fence needs to stand robust against the elements, be resilient to pests, and maintain its appearance with minimal upkeep.

Moreover, a fence serves as a security barrier, ensuring privacy and safety for those within its bounds. The choice between cedar and redwood isn't just about which looks better, but also about which one serves these functional needs most effectively.

As we delve deeper into the specifics of cedar versus redwood, these factors will weigh heavily on the scale of decision-making.

Cedar vs Redwood Fence: Which is the Better Lumber Choice?

Now, let’s get into what you really came here for - help choosing between a redwood vs cedar fence. We’ll compare and contrast these two lumber choices against the criteria we feel matters most - from appearance to cost, longevity, maintenance, and more.


Both cedar and redwood step up to the plate when it comes to aesthetic appeal.

Cedar is renowned for its distinct reddish-brown hue. It tends to darken over time, giving your fence a classic, aged look that many homeowners covet. This timber is rich with natural oils that not only protect it but lend it a radiant sheen under sunlight.

Redwood, on the other hand, flaunts a slightly more vibrant shade of red. However, cedar's grain patterns are often more intricate and eye-catching, making each fence board look like a unique work of nature's art.


Let's talk numbers. Cost can be a decisive factor in choosing a fence material. But, it’s important to take this into account with a grain of salt, as you typically get what you pay for.

That being said, cedar, especially Western Red Cedar, is typically more pocket-friendly than redwood. While both woods are premium choices, redwood often carries a heftier price tag due to its limited availability and the fact that it primarily grows on the U.S. West Coast.

Cedar, meanwhile, is more widely available and thus more accessible price-wise without compromising on quality. For homeowners aiming for durability and beauty without breaking the bank, cedar usually stands out as the clear winner.


A fence is an investment, so how long it stands tall matters. So, how long does a cedar fence last? Cedar boasts a remarkable lifespan of a few decades, especially if maintained well. Its natural oils act as repellents against pests, including termites.

Moreover, cedar is highly resistant to decay, ensuring that it remains intact for years, even in regions with a lot of moisture. It doesn’t necessarily require treatment, either.

Redwood, while robust and naturally resistant to pests, tends to be a bit more susceptible to environmental wear and tear, especially if not properly treated.

In terms of longevity, cedar takes the lead, promising homeowners a fence that won't just look good but will stand the test of time.


Which requires less maintenance as it pertains to the cedar vs redwood fence debate? There’s a distinct advantage to cedar here.

Cedar's inherent resistance to decay means it requires less frequent treatments compared to redwood. A periodic cleaning, paired with a sealant every few years, ensures cedar fences remain both functional and visually appealing.

Redwood, while still robust, might demand more diligent attention, especially in areas prone to fungus or high moisture levels. Notably, cedar's natural oils repel pests and contribute to its low-maintenance charm, giving homeowners more peace of mind and less work.

Natural Aromatics

There's no denying the allure of natural wood scents. Both cedar and redwood fences release pleasant, woodsy aromas, especially when freshly installed.

Cedar, in particular, exudes a fragrant scent that many homeowners find not only delightful but also nostalgic, reminiscent of serene forests and nature retreats. Beyond the sensory pleasure, cedar's aroma is more than just a smell - it acts as a natural insect repellant.

While redwood's scent is equally pleasant, cedar's aromatic properties have the dual benefit of charm and functionality.

Environmental Impact

The environmental impact of a cedar vs redwood fence cannot be overlooked. So, is cedar fencing sustainable? Cedar trees mature quickly, making them a more renewable resource.

Cedar forests, especially those in sustainable forestry programs, are replenished at a rate that keeps the ecological balance in check.

On the other hand, redwood trees take much longer to mature. While there are sustainable redwood forestry practices, the rate of replanting and growth doesn't match that of cedar.

Additionally, cedar's longevity and resistance mean fewer replacements and less waste over time. For those keen on making eco-friendly choices, cedar emerges as the green choice, aligning environmental consciousness with quality and aesthetics.

So, Should You Go With Cedar or Redwood Fence Boards?

So, which is better - a redwood vs cedar fence? You may be starting to lean one way or the other after reading along thus far. If not, here’s our say on the matter: cedar has an edge in almost every way.

We think it looks better, it costs a bit less, and it lasts longer. It also smells amazing and requires very minimal maintenance, if any. Plus, it’s the more environmentally friendly choice - what more could you ask for?

It’s also the best type of fence for sound barrier if you’re looking for a fence that helps you find a sense of calm amidst the chaos of your surrounding area. Learn more about the cost of sound barrier fencing or how to build a sound barrier fence in our blog.

Otherwise, if you’re ready to get started with your next building project, head over to Quality Cedar Products for high-quality cedar lumber paired with world-class support!

Start Your Project on the Right Foot With Top Grade Lumber at Quality Cedar Products!

While cedar fencing has an undeniable edge over redwood, where you source your lumber matters. That’s why contractors and lumber yards across North America trust Quality Cedar Products for cedar lumber for sale - and cedar fencing specifically.

We sort and grade our lumber ourselves by hand to maintain strict quality standards. This allows you to place your order with confidence knowing you’re getting the quality you deserve.

You don’t just have to take our word for it, either. Your order is backed by our satisfaction guarantee. If you’re not happy with the quality of your lumber, we’ll turn our delivery truck around and you won’t pay - simple as that!

This is why we’re not just the premier choice for cedar fencing across Canada and the US. Customers count on us for everything from a sound barrier fence to cedar deck boards, cedar siding, and more. So, reach out today to learn more or request a quote - as it’s time to wrap up this debate on redwood vs cedar fence boards.

Wrapping Up Our Redwood vs Cedar Fence Debate

Both timbers bring their unique strengths to the table in the cedar vs redwood fence debate. That being said, only one is right for your needs - and we believe that to be cedar fencing. It has the edge in terms of appearance, longevity, maintenance, aromatic qualities, and environmental impact.

As you weigh the pros and cons of redwood vs cedar fence boards, remember that the right choice in fencing material plays a pivotal role in the longevity, aesthetics, and overall satisfaction of your project.

Don't just build a fence - create a lasting legacy for your home by reaping the incredible benefits of cedar fencing right here at Quality Cedar Products!

G&B Wholesale Lumber Incorporated does not assume any liability for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of the information provided in this blog post. The reader is solely responsible for any actions taken based on the information presented. Any reliance on the information is at the reader's own risk.

G&B Wholesale Lumber Incorporated is not responsible for any loss, injury, or damage that may occur as a result of following the suggestions, tips, or recommendations provided in this blog post. Building projects involve inherent risks, and it is essential to exercise caution, obtain proper permits, and engage qualified professionals to ensure safety and compliance with all applicable laws and regulations. The inclusion of external links, references, or recommendations in this blog post does not constitute endorsement or guarantee the quality, reliability, or suitability of the linked sources. The reader should independently verify the information and assess its relevance to their specific circumstances. The author reserves the right to modify, update, or remove the content of this blog post at any time without prior notice. It is recommended to check for the most recent updates or consult with professionals to ensure the information is current and applicable. By reading this blog post, the reader acknowledges and accepts the above disclaimer and agrees to use the information provided responsibly and at their own discretion.

14 views0 comments


bottom of page